The International Comparative Legal Guide to:
Telecommunication Laws & Regulations 2008
|
|
|
| |
Published by Global Legal Group with contributions from:
A practical insight to cross-border Telecommunication Laws and Regulations
www.ICLG.co.uk
The International Comparative Legal Guide to
- Arculli Fong & Ng
- Bär & Karrer
- Brinkhof
- CCdM&A - Cugia Cuomo de Marco & Associati
- Cechová & Partners
- Cocalis & Psarras
- Corrs Chambers Westgarth
- Djingov, Gouginski, Kyutchukov & Velichkov
- Dr. Norbert Wiesinger, Law Offices
- EsinIsmen Hukuk Bürosu
- Forgó, Varga & Partners
- Gencs Valters Law Firm
- Gilbert + Tobin
- Gómez-Acebo & Pombo Abogados -Greenberg Traurig LLP
- GVTH - Advocates
- Harbottle & Lewis
- Heuking Kühn Lüer Wojtek
- Jadek & Pensa
|
- Kim & Chang
- kines
- King & Wood
- Kromann Reumert
- LG@vocats
- Mannheimer Swartling
- MGF Webb
- Mundie e AdvogadosNorton Rose
- Olswang
- PLMJ - Sociedade de Advogados
Poovaya & Co.
- Prieto & Carrizosa Attorneys at Law
Rios Ferrer, Guillen-Llarena, Treviño y Rivera, S.C.
- Roschier, Attorneys Ltd.
- Saladzius & Partners
Sanchez Elia - Abogados
- Sorainen
- Traple Konarski Podrecki
- Tuca Zbarcea & Asociatii
- Webber Wentzel Bowens
Wikborg, Rein & Co.
- William Fry |
|
LIC. RICARDO RÍOS FERRER
LIC. FRANCISCO JAVIER TREVIÑO MORENO
Partner rrios@riosferrer.com.mx
Partner ftrevino@riosferrer.com.mx
Back |
| |
1 Framework
1.1 What are the overall policies and objectives for the
electronic communications industry and have these been
published in draft or final form?
The National Development Plan 2007 - 2012 “NDP”, issued by the Executive Branch, has as its purpose the establishment of general objectives of the nation as well as strategies and priorities during
this administration. Such NDP rules the actions of the government in order to provide a clear course and direction to the action of the federal administration.
In connection with telecommunications, the NDP establishes the following as main policies:
increase the competition among concessionaires; promote the design and development of strategies that ease the use of information and communication technologies: promote the development of technology infrastructure; and develop mechanisms and all necessary conditions to promote investment in the creation of infrastructure and services in the telecommunication field.
1.2 Is Mexico a member of the World Trade Organisation?
Yes, Mexico has been a WTO member since January 1, 1995.
1.3 Has Mexico made commitments under the GATS/GATT regarding telecommunications and has Mexico adopted the WTO Basic Telecommunications Agreement?
Mexico has executed the following Schedules of Specific Commitments regarding telecommunications:
GATS/SC/56, dated April 15, 1994; and GATS/SC/56/ Suppl.2, dated April 11, 1997.
1.4 How is the provision of electronic communications networks or services regulated? Is the provision of electronic communications networks or services open to
competition in Mexico?
Electronic communications networks or services are mainly regulated by the Federal Telecommunications Law; however, other regulations such as the Federal Radio and Television Law; General Communication Means Law, regulation for commercialisation of long distance and international long distance telecommunication services, the Via Satellite Communication Regulation; the Public Telephony Service Regulation, Restricted Audio and Television Service Regulation, Telecommunication Regulation, Foreign
Investment Law and Regulation thereof as well as the Federal Economic Competition Law and Regulation also regulate specific fields in the Mexican telecommunications sector.
1.5 Which are the regulatory and competition law authorities? How are their roles differentiated?
The primary authority in the telecommunications sector is the Ministry of Communications and Transportation “SCT”. The Ministry delegates most of its telecommunications functions to the Federal
Telecommunications Commission, an administrative agency with technical and operational autonomy formed by five commissionaires where one of them is the President of the Commission. Although not telecommunication authorities exclusively, the following authorities also take part in most telecommunication matters:
- The Foreign Investment National Commission (Comision Nacional de Inversion Extranjera), dependant of the Ministry of Economics, that approves or rejects foreign participation beyond allowed limits in certain circumstances, and foreign participation of non-voting or neutral shares in all cases, amongst other powers; and
- The Federal Economic Competition Commission, which is in charge of protecting the competition process by preventing monopolies, monopolistic practices and other restrictions that might affect the efficient operation of the market. The Federal Economic Competition Commission is dependant of the Ministry of Economics.
|
1.6 Are decisions of the national regulatory authority able to be appealed? To which court or body?
Depending on the particular case, any or all of the following apply:
- Administrative Review process before the hierarchical superior of the appealed authority;
- Annulment Action, before the Administrative and Tax
- Federal Justice Court; and
- Constitutional Review, before Federal Courts whenever the bill of rights are violated by the authority.
|
|
|
2 Licensing
2.1 If a licence or other authorisation is required to install or operate electronic communications networks or provide services over them, please briefly describe the process and timescales.
Depending on the actual telecommunication service, a concession, permit or registration is required as follows:
a) Concession, required to render the following services.
Use, enjoy or exploit a frequency band in Mexican territory, except the free use and official spectrum:
This kind of concession is granted throughout public bidding in which the federal government has the right to receive an economic consideration for the granting of the corresponding concession.
The Ministry of Communications and Transportation is in charge of releasing frequency bands from the spectrum onto a public bidding in order for them to be exploited by any interested party as long as general conditions are met. The Ministry will announce and invite any interested party to participate in the public bidding with the proper time in order for participants to prepare their offer.
These concessions are granted for up to a 20-year term that may be renewed for the same term as originally granted, at the discretion of the Ministry. In order for the concessionaries to assure the renewal of their concession they must have complied with the conditions established in the concession title, request the renewal before the
beginning of the last fifth of the term of the concession. The Ministry shall have a response for the renewal application in no more than 180 calendar days, counted from the day the application was submitted.
Concessions for Telecommunications Public Networks, to install, operate or exploit public telecommunications networks:
Public telecommunications network is understood as the telecommunications network through which telecommunications services are commercially exploited. Such network does not include the telecommunications terminal equipment of users nor the
telecommunications network located beyond the terminal connection point.
Parties interested in obtaining a concession to install, operate or exploit a public telecommunication networks must file an application for the approval by the Ministry.
The Ministry analyses the abovementioned application and evaluates it within the following 120 calendar days. Throughout this period the Ministry may request additional information from the parties.
Once the requirements are complied with to the full satisfaction of the Ministry the concession will be granted.
The term of the concession may be granted for up to 30 years. Such term may be renewed for a term equal to the original concession. In order to renew the concession the concessionaire must have had complied with the conditions established in the concession and file the corresponding request.
Having this type of concession will not grant the right to make use of the spectrum. In order to be able to use and exploit a frequency band a particular concession must be granted.
Private telecommunications networks:
These require neither a concession nor a permit unless they make use of a frequency band in the spectrum; in that case it will be necessary to obtain a concession for that purpose.
Concession for communication via satellite:
To occupy and exploit geostationary orbital positions and satellite orbits assigned to the country, and exploit their respective frequency bands.
These concessions are granted through a public bidding process.
Foreign satellite system concessions or landing rights concessions:
The Ministry may grant concessions for the right of emission and reception of signals and frequency bands associated with foreign satellite systems covering Mexican territory.
Telecommunication concessions will only be granted to Mexican entities incorporated under Mexican Law. Foreign investment restrictions apply in each particular case.
b) Permits, required to render the following services.
Establish and operate or exploit a telecommunications services reseller, who must not own telecommunications infrastructure.
Install, operate or exploit earth transmission stations:
Parties interested in obtaining a telecommunication permit must file an application before the Ministry including the requirements established for concession applications.
Once the application is filed, the Ministry will analyse and evaluate the documentation and application within the following 90 calendar days. During such term, further information or documentation may be required to the filing party.
Once all requirements have been satisfactorily fulfilled by the interested party the corresponding permit will be granted.
c) Registrations.
Value added services are defined by the applicable regulation as any service that affect the content, format, code, storage or aspects of the information and that commercialise additional, different or restructured information or imply interaction of the user.
Aregistration before the corresponding authority is enough to allow the interested party to render the following services:
audio text;
remote data processing;
electronic data exchange (intercambio electronico de datos);
email or fax;
video text;
voice mail;
teletext;
remote consultation to data bases; and
others. |
|
2.2 What other requirements, permits or approvals must be met or obtained before networks may be installed or operated and services provided?
In addition to the aforementioned, foreign investment as well as competition (antitrust) requirements must be met.
a) Foreign Investment.
The foreign investment regulation establishes as a general rule that foreign investment within the telecommunication industry is limited to 49% except for cellular telephone where there is no limitation.
Activities restricted by this rule are the use of radio/electromagnetic spectrum in Mexico, the installation and operation of public telecommunications networks, the occupation of geostationary orbital slots, and the emission and reception of signals from foreign satellites.
Foreign investors may invest in the capital of Mexican companies engaged in the restricted businesses referred to above provided they do so as minority shareholders or hold shares with limited voting rights, and in either case, agree to consider themselves as Mexican nationals with respect to their interest in the company and not to invoke the protection of their own government in the event of a dispute, under penalty of forfeiting their interest to the state for violation of the agreement.
Notwithstanding the aforementioned, the applicable foreign investment regulation establishes that neutral investment can be made in Mexican entities to exceed the limitation in economic terms, never in control or voting matters, with the prior approval of the Commission.
b) Competition (antitrust).
The Federal Competition Commission (CFC), as a decentralised agency of the Federal Public Administration, is the authority in charge of dealing with competition issues in the Mexican market.
The purpose of the competition regulation and authorities is to rule on economic competition, monopolies and free market access. It is binding to all sectors of the economic activity within Mexico. |
2.3 May licences or other authorisations be transferred and if so under what conditions?
Concessions and permits may be assigned in the following cases:
a) Acquisition of the company holding the concession or permit title. In this case, the interested investor may buy or acquire control of a company holding a concession or permit title.
b) Assignment of the title. The Federal Telecommunications Law establishes that to authorise the partial or complete assignment of the concession title it will be necessary to file an application for authorisation from the Ministry and at least 3 years have elapsed
since the date the concession was granted.
Once the application has been submitted, the Ministry will analyse and evaluate it and will have a response within 90 calendar days,
ounted from the day the application was filed. The assignee has to agree to fulfil any pending obligations and assumes the conditions imposed for that purpose by the Ministry.
In case where the purpose of the assignment is to transfer the rights to operate and exploit a public telecommunications network or a frequency band to another concessionaire or permit holder rendering similar services in the same geographical area,
authorisation from the Federal Economic Competition Commission must be previously obtained in order for the Ministry to authorise the corresponding assignment.
|
2.4 What is the usual or typical stated duration of licences or other authorisations?
Frequency band concessions may be granted for up to 20 years. Such term may be renewed for a term equal to the original concession. In order to renew the concession the concessionaire must have had complied with the conditions established in the concession and file the corresponding request.
Public telecommunication networks concessions may be granted for up to 30 years. Such term may be renewed for a term equal to the original concession. To renew the concession the concessionaire must have complied with the conditions established in the concession and file the corresponding request. |
3 Public and Private Works
3.1 Are there specific legal or administrative provisions dealing with access to public and private land in order to install telecommunications infrastructure?
To access Public lands, specific Federal, State or Municipal permitsmust be obtained, as appropriate, and the network must run through a public right of way.
There is no specific provision dealing with access to private land.
3.2 Do any specific rules exist which assist in securing or enforcing rights of way over public or private land, for the installation of network infrastructure?
The FTL establishes that in case of federal rights or ways or infrastructure (pipelines, power towers, etc.) if technically feasible, these must give access to the telecommunications network.
Otherwise, a claim could be filed with the Telecommunications Commission and/or the Federal Competition Commission.
3.3 Is there a specific planning or zoning regime that applies to the installation of network infrastructure?
Yes and it varies from municipality to municipality.
3.4 Are there any rules requiring established operators to share their infrastructure, e.g. masts, sites, ducts or cables?
No specific rules under the FTL; in some cases certain provisions have been inserted into concession titles. Generally, these are voluntary agreements. |
|
|
4 Access and Interconnection
4.1 Is network-to-network interconnection and access mandated, and what are the criteria for qualifying for the benefits of interconnection?
The FTL establishes that concessionaires must adopt open designs to allow interconnecting and interoperating its networks.
Concessionaires must interconnect their networks through an interconnection agreement.
4.2 How are interconnection or access disputes resolved? Does the national regulatory have jurisdiction to adjudicate and impose a legally binding solution?
The Telecommunications Commission has the authority to determine its final terms and conditions if the parties fail to reach an agreement after a term following notice given to the Telecommunications Commission that such an agreement began to be negotiated.
4.3 Are charges for interconnection and/or network access subject to price or cost regulation and, if so, how?
Prices related to interconnection are not subject to regulation. The parties are, however, compelled to act under interconnection reciprocity between concessionaires providing similar services and may not provide discounts on volume nor discriminatory practices. Rates are subject to registration.
4.4 In the local loop are existing owners of access infrastructure required to unbundle their facilities and if so, on what terms or regulatory controls?
It is not mandatory to unbundle their facilities
4.5 How are existing interconnection and access regulatoryconditions to be applied to new network technologies suchas so-called next generation networks or IP-basednetworks?
By the issuance of administrative guidelines as well as technical standards. |
|
5 Price and Consumer Regulation
5.1 Are (i) retail or (ii) wholesale price controls imposed on any operator in relation to fixed, mobile, or other services?
No, they are not.
5.2 Is the provision of electronic communications services to consumers subject to any special rules and if so, in what principal respects?
Consumer Protection Rules, enforced by the Consumers Protection Agency, apply to any service rendered to final users, including telecommunication services.
5.3. Are there any rules governing use and retention of customer call information?
Consumer call information may be used for directories if the consumer has not asked that it remain confidential. Data may not be otherwise placed into the market.
|
|
6 Numbering
6.1 How are telephone numbers and network identifying codes allocated and by whom?
Telephone numbers and network identifying codes are allocated by the Telecommunications Commission and through Signal, Number and Technical Plans.
6.2 Are there any special rules which govern the use of telephone numbers?
No, other than those mentioned in question 6.1 above.
6.3 How are telephone numbers made available for network use and how are such numbers activated for use by customers?
Numbers are given by the Telecommunications Commission and activation is made by allocation of a number to a contract.
6.4 What are the basic rules applicable to the ‘porting’ (i.e. transfer) of telephone numbers (fixed and mobile).
FTC is currently working in the elaboration of a Portability Plan that will apply to the porting of telephone numbers in Mexico |
|
7 Fees
7.1 What fees and levies are payable and to whom with respect to the grant of a licence or other authorisation for the installation or use of network infrastructure or the provision of communication services?
Depending on the specific telecommunication service a governmental fee applies under the Federal Law of Fees. |
|
8 Submarine Cables
8.1 What are the main rules governing the bringing into Mexico’s territorial waters, and the landing, of submarine cables? Are there any special authorisations required or fees to be paid with respect to submarine cables?
The Regulation for the Use and Management of Territorial Sea, Navigable Routes, Beaches, Terrestrial-Maritime Federal Zones and Terrains is the main rule applicable, and it creates the obligation to have a telecommunications concession in order to install a submarine cable in Mexican territorial waters. |
|
9 Radio Frequency Spectrum
9.1 Is the use of radio frequency spectrum specifically regulated and if so, by which authority?
The Ministry is the main authority in charge of regulating on the radio frequency spectrum under the Federal Telecommunications Law.
9.2 In the grant of spectrum rights are distinctions made between mobile, fixed and satellite usage?
The Frequency Attribution National Chart, allocates different uses to diverse frequencies of the spectrum, based on ITU recommendations and bilateral coordination arrangements.
9.3 How is the installation of satellite earth stations and their use for up-linking and down-linking regulated?
Uplink stations require a permit. Downlink-only stations do not require any permit or concession.
9.4 How is the use of radio frequency spectrum authorised in Mexico? Do the procedures available include spectrum auctions and comparative selection of candidates?
Yes, auctions are used. However, the Supreme Court recently ruled auctions as unconstitutional. The Ministry and the Congress will have to create new competitive and comparative processes in lieu of an auction.
9.5 Can the use of spectrum be made licence-exempt? If so, under what conditions?
No, it cannot.
9.6 If licence or other authorisation fees are payable for the use of radio frequency spectrum, how are these applied and calculated?
There is a fee imposed on the amount of capacity used calculated on a per MHz fee.
9.7 Are spectrum licences able to be traded or sub-licensed and if so on what conditions?
Spectrum licences may be assigned in whole or in part only after 3 years have lapsed after the date of grant and certain conditions apply as noted before |
|
10 Interception
10.1 What are the essential rules applicable to the interception of messages, traffic data and other call records? Which rules apply to the retention of such call data, and over which period(s)?
It is prohibited to intercept, disclose, or make unauthorised use of messages, data or record without a Court order. |
|
11 The Internet
11.1 Are services over the Internet regulated in any different way to other electronic communications services? Which rules, if any, govern access to the Internet at a wholesale
and/or retail level?
Yes. Internet is subject to a Value Added registration, thus conditions imposed on concessions and permits do not apply.
This policy may change as voice services over the Internet expand without the same regulatory burdens as in an ordinary telephone concession.
11.2 Are there any rules to prevent, restrict or otherwise govern Internet or email communications, in particular, marketing and advertising communications?
The Consumer Protection Law governs commercial relationships between suppliers and consumers in transactions carried out through the use of electronic or optical means or through any other technology. |
|
12 USO
12.1 Is there a concept of universal service obligation; if so how is this defined, regulated and funded?
There is no regulation establishing a universal service obligation. However, there is a general obligation to have social coverage of public networks. An agreement was reached by operators and the Ministry to create a trust that will fund universal services-related costs. |
|
13 Foreign Ownership Rules
13.1 Are there any rules restricting direct or indirect foreign ownership interests in electronic communications companies whether in fixed, mobile, satellite or other wireless operations?
The foreign investment regulation establishes, as a general rule, that foreign investment within the telecommunication industry is limited to 49% except for cellular telephone, that has no limitation.
Activities restricted by this rule are the use of radio/electromagnetic spectrum in Mexico, the installation and operation of public telecommunications networks, the occupation of geostationary orbital slots, and the emission and reception of signals from foreign satellites.
Foreign investors may invest in the capital of Mexican companies engaged in the restricted businesses referred to above provided they do so as minority shareholders or hold shares with limited voting rights, and in either case, agree to consider themselves as Mexican nationals with respect to their interest in the company and not to invoke the protection of their own government in the event of a dispute, under penalty of forfeiting their interest to the state for violation of the agreement.
Notwithstanding the aforementioned, the applicable foreign investment regulation establishes that neutral investment can be made in Mexican entities in order to allow foreigners to hold greater economic interests in the capital of Mexican companies in restricted areas; such investments are not considered as direct foreign investment and are not considered in the 49% foreign investment limitation. |
|
14 Future plans
14.1 Are there any imminent and significant changes to the legal and regulatory regime for electronic communications?
Portability Technical Guidelines. These will define the signalling formats that will allow local and long distance networks to identify the concessionaires holding the origin or
destiny numbers.
Interconnection Technical Plan. This will establish the main guidelines and obligations by concessionaires in this matter.
Amendments to the Federal Radio and Television Law and to the Federal Telecommunications Law, resulting from recent Supreme Court rulings that held several provisions thereunder as unconstitutional. |
|